Review only for logged in users?

Hi,

I added a separate reviews page to my website because according to your documentation this would allow customers to leave a review without being logged in.

However, on this page, I’m presented with this message: https://imgur.com/a/HLFb2eR

For reference, these are my site’s comments settings: https://imgur.com/a/dznTrlc

How can I assure that customers don’t need to be logged in to leave a comment? What settings do I have to adjust?

Best regards,

Stefan