Attribute color swatches – settings conflict

Hello
This website is in development

I have 12 products all with 2 attributes. Color and Size.
Each product has its own color attribute swatches. Some of these swatch names are identical. The individual color swatches are different RGB values with each product.

When I created this new product (Siser EasyWeed® Stretch). The “color” attribute has 57 swatches . These seem to take on the color definitions from other products. Seems like its getting the definitions from other product’s color swatch definitions with the same name. Like its conflicting?

From within the product itself,
When I set the Color attribute’s “swatch settings” from within the product it keeps going back to global default instead of taking on my designated settings. This happens everytime I hit Save (Update) the product. It will not retain them.
Lastly this same product looses all 57 swatch definitions upon saving/updating the product as well. This happens everytime I Save (Update) the product

These problems alone make me lose all my work – very frustrating and very concerning as it seems buggy.

Can you look at this and fix the issues or tell me what I am doing wrong?